Call the Midwife: A Different View of Jane Austen’s World

Posted

in

by

Try to think back: how many times have you read a JAFF story where someone gives birth? In those stories, was a midwife involved in the delivery, or did a doctor make the catch?

Not long ago I picked up a book that readers of Jane Austen fan fiction would be sure to love: A Midwife’s Tale: The Life of Martha Ballard, Based on Her Diary, 1785-1812. I highly recommend it to anyone who wants to improve their understanding of medicine, the role of women, and just general life in the regency period. Martha Ballard lived in New England, but so many things described in her diary also apply to the world of Jane Austen!

Diary of a Midwife
Diary of a Midwife

For example, take the role of midwives in childbirth. Most births were attended by a midwife, not a doctor, especially if the expectant mother was from a middle class or poor family. There was no formal training system for midwives; they learned their craft through an informal apprenticeship with an established midwife. A young woman, either married or single, would usually start assisting the local midwife during deliveries and work herself into the role, learning as she went and eventually replacing the older woman. In her lifetime, Martha Ballard assisted with the delivery of over 800 children.

But midwives were not limited to helping with deliveries. They provided pre and post natal care as well, and also helped with general infections and “women’s complaints.” They dispensed herbal remedies, cared for the sick, helped neighbors with household tasks, and sometimes even assisted with preparing bodies for burial. A midwife was a key member of the community!

Like doctors, midwives had to travel to their patients, and Martha Ballard’s diary describes traveling through conditions that would make us cringe even today. Snow, ice, swollen rivers, and dangerous thunderstorms were all a part of the job and were dutifully recorded. Sometimes Martha even made these treacherous journeys while she herself was pregnant!

One of the most interesting parts of Martha’s journal, for me, involved how she was paid. Let’s say that a patient’s family had no cash but did have a large credit built up at the local center of trade. For example, if the farmer had sold eggs, barley and honey to the local store over the past month they might have forty shillings of credit with the store. They could write out a note to the store directing the store owner to transfer ten of those shillings to Martha’s name instead. Martha had quite a chore keeping track of who had paid her what amount, and in what form. When she had a large credit with the store, she might also sign over some of her credit to pay debts to still another person. The shopkeeper and everyone involved had to track these transfers carefully. It was eye opening to see this early form of banking at work.

Another interesting part of the diary was the number of babies Martha delivered who were conceived out of wedlock—perhaps as high as fifteen percent. The society of the day seemed to be less concerned with when a child was conceived and more concerned with making sure two parents were around to support it after it was born. Sometimes, if the alleged father proved reluctant to take responsibility for his offspring, Martha might become involved with legal proceedings to help establish paternity. In those cases, Martha’s records of the mother’s living arrangements and other details were taken seriously and were used in court to establish support for the mother and child.

Reading this book, I couldn’t help thinking how all of these rich details might be incorporated into a JAFF based story. Imagine, for example, that Charlotte Lucas opts to train as a midwife rather than marry Mr. Collins. How would that affect her standing in the community? Perhaps a married Elizabeth Darcy is having difficulty delivering her first child, and the midwife she trusts argues with the doctor that Darcy insists on bringing into the delivery room. I would love a scene where Wickham denies being the father of Lydia’s child but a midwife steps forward with evidence that even he cannot deny! The possibilities are endless.

Did any of this information about midwives surprise you? How can you picture a midwife being involved in a Jane Austen story? I’d love to hear your ideas! Please leave your thoughts below!

12 responses to “Call the Midwife: A Different View of Jane Austen’s World”

  1. Jean Stillman Avatar
    Jean Stillman

    I really enjoyed this very interesting account! I always enjoy the books where a midwife is involved in the delivery of the new Darcy heir. I would love to see a more intelligent version of Fanny Bennet in such a role. Or even a tale where Mr. Bennet has died, and Jane and/or Elizabeth take on the role as midwife in order to help support their family. Such possibilities!

    1. elaineowenauthor207097889 Avatar
      elaineowenauthor207097889

      I can see Elizabeth being a good midwife, and maybe Mary as well. Jane doesn’t strike me as the midwife type! Then again, since Elizabeth would presumably have to ride a horse to get to her patients, maybe this wouldn’t work for her either.

  2. clearlyoriginal351ea862c4 Avatar
    clearlyoriginal351ea862c4

    Proceed to writing this series, please.

    1. elaineowenauthor207097889 Avatar
      elaineowenauthor207097889

      Ha ha! Your wish is my command! Let’s see . . .

      Elizabeth turns Darcy down at Hunsford. A couple years go by and Mr. Bennet dies. Elizabeth becomes a midwife in town, where she helps Georgiana, who is now married, to give birth. She and Darcy meet again and they realize together that Georgiana’s husband is a cad. Darcy feels guilty because he arranged her marriage. Georgiana’s husband dies under mysterious circumstances and Georgiana is accused of causing his death. Elizabeth provides evidence that exonerates her. Darcy loses all his pride and proposes, but Elizabeth has to decide if she really believes that he has changed or not.
      Is that good enough? 🙂

  3. cindie snyder Avatar
    cindie snyder

    You have some great ideas! Very interesting post it seems midwives went above and beyond to do their duties! Whoo! Martha sounds like she was a great midwife delivering all those babies, she really must have known her job! Way to go Martha!

    1. elaineowenauthor207097889 Avatar
      elaineowenauthor207097889

      There was so much more in this book than what I could include in a short summary! Martha commented on social conditions and gave details about symptoms she observed and how she treated various illnesses. The diary stops a month or two before she dies, and by that time, I really felt like I knew her. 🙁

  4. Glory Avatar
    Glory

    Oh rabbit holes of ideas are fun to read. I love the idea of Charlotte becoming a midwife. I can see with her practical way of looking at life would be a good fit.

    1. elaineowenauthor207097889 Avatar
      elaineowenauthor207097889

      Yes, I think she would be good at it. But I’m guessing not many daughters of gentlemen ever took up a profession that required so much manual labor.

  5. Anne Madison Avatar

    If you are ever driving down the Blue Ridge Parkway (probably not this year), watch in Southern Virginia for a tiny, unimpressive little cabin set in a beautiful green clearing. It is the home of Mrs. Orlean Hawkes Puckett, who delivered more than 500 babies until her death at age 94 in 1939. The women in the backcountry of the Blue Ridge relied on her just as women of the Regency relied on their midwives. As I recall, she lost something on the order of 15 children of her own before being trained by an older woman to take over the job. There is a book about her if anybody’s interested. I think I can find it.

    1. elaineowenauthor207097889 Avatar
      elaineowenauthor207097889

      Wow, what an amazing woman!!! I can’t imagine so much tragedy for one person, and then to take up a profession that would be so closely connected to that tragedy.

      1. Anne Madison Avatar

        I’ve driven (and ridden) a lot on the Parkway, and I never neglect to pay the cabin a visit. I don’t believe the cabin itself has ever been open to the public, but the little clearing, the trees, the cabin, and the shed are such a beautiful, tender spot. I am on the trail of her biography, and when I find it I will let you know.

  6. Anne Madison Avatar

    Well, I should have waited a few minutes more before replying. You can find the book in gently used condition at Better World Books, a favorite haunt of mine, or new on Amazon for $11.

    Better World Books:
    https://www.betterworldbooks.com/product/detail/orlean-puckett-the-life-of-a-mountain-midwife-1844-1939-9781887905725

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Always Austen

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading